How we handle reviews and reports
Reviews and photos are published straight away
We do not check them first. We look through new photos from time to time, not every day, and may remove one without telling the person who posted it.
We do not edit reviews
We never change a review's words, and we do not remove a review for being negative.
Reporting a review
Members: tap "Report" under any review or reply. The review is hidden while an administrator looks, and its rating still counts. We aim to look within 2 working days, and we look first at reports about children or safety. We tell you, and the author, what we decided. We do not tell the author who reported them, unless the law requires us to.
If you are not a member
Use Contact us and choose "Ask for a photo or review to be removed". A person reads every message. Nothing is hidden automatically when you send the form. If a photo shows you or your child, we take it down. The member who posted it is not told who asked.
Venue owners
A confirmed owner can reply once under each review. An owner can never edit, hide, reorder or remove a review.
The most serious cases
If a child is in immediate danger, call 000. Child abuse material is removed at once and reported to the police.
If you are not satisfied
You can complain to the eSafety Commissioner (opens in a new tab), Australia's online safety regulator.
The policy in full
This is our policy for publishing, hiding, restoring and removing reviews.
1. Reviews and photos are published straight away
A review from a signed-in member with a confirmed email address appears at once, with its photos. We do not check reviews or photos before they are published. A word filter blocks some offensive words as you type. Every photo is rebuilt as a new, smaller image, and its location details are removed.
An administrator looks through newly posted photos from time to time, not every day, and removes any that should not be there. So a photo that breaks the rules can be on show until someone reports it or we come across it. If you see one, please report it.
2. We do not edit reviews, and we do not remove a review for being negative
- Our administrators never change the words of a review. If part of a review breaks a rule, we remove the photo or the whole review, or ask the author to delete it and post it again.
- A negative review that follows the rules stays up. "The venue did not like it" is never a reason to remove a review.
- A review is removed only under a named Community rule, and the author is told which one.
- Photos are different. We can remove a photo that breaks the rules, or that we judge does not belong on a guide for families. When we remove one while looking through new photos, or because someone asked us through Contact us, we do not send you a message. When we remove one after a member reports your review, we tell you which rule it broke. Removing a photo never changes the words of your review or its rating. If you think we removed a photo by mistake, write to us and a person will look again.
- The number of reviews is shown beside every rating, so you can see how many opinions a rating rests on.
- You can delete your own review at any time, and then write a new one. Its words and ratings cannot be changed once it is posted.
3. Thumbs up and thumbs down
Signed-in members can give a review a thumbs up or a thumbs down: one vote each, which you can change. We show the number of thumbs up. A thumbs down is not shown, and it never hides anything; it tells us a review may need a look.
4. Reporting a review
Every review has one Report control. It covers the review's words and its photos. You need to be signed in. You choose a reason:
- sexual or nude content, or a child shown in a way that is not OK;
- shows or names someone who has not agreed, including "my child";
- bullying, threats, harassment or hate;
- violent, dangerous or illegal content;
- spam, advertising or a fake review;
- not about this place, or wrong information;
- something else (with a note).
What happens next:
- The review's words and photos are hidden from everyone else straight away, until an administrator has looked. The author can still see their own words, with a note that the review is being checked.
- Its rating still counts while it is hidden. Hiding a review does not lift a venue's score.
- You see a reference number, and we tell you the outcome.
- An administrator looks. We aim to look within 2 working days, and we look first at reports about children or safety.
- The administrator restores the review, restores it without one of its photos, or removes the review under a named rule. If the report did not hide the review, the administrator can also leave it as it is, and records why.
- The author is told when their review is hidden, and when it is restored or removed, with the rule, and can reply to us.
- We do not tell the author who reported them, unless the law requires us to.
Guards against misuse. Reporting is not a way to bury a fair review:
- a report from the venue's own confirmed owner is looked at, but does not hide the review;
- a review that an administrator has checked and restored cannot be hidden again by another report;
- a member whose reports are repeatedly rejected (at least 3 in 12 months, and more rejected than upheld) keeps the right to report, but their reports no longer hide anything;
- a thumbs down never hides anything.
5. If you are not a member
Use the Contact us form at the foot of every page and choose "Ask for a photo or review to be removed". Tell us which photo or review, and why. You do not need an account, and you do not need to prove who you are.
A person reads every message. We aim to look at removal requests within 2 working days. If it is urgent, say so at the start of your message. Nothing is hidden automatically when you send the form.
If a photo shows you or your child, we take it down. The member who posted it is not told who asked.
6. Venue owners
- A venue's owner or manager can use "Claim this venue". We confirm each claim ourselves, by phone or email, using contact details for the venue that we have checked. We do not accept a claim on the claimant's word alone.
- A confirmed owner can post one public reply under each review of their venue, and can edit or remove their own reply. Replies are labelled as from the venue.
- An owner can never edit, hide, reorder or remove a review, and never sees more about a reviewer than the public sees.
- An owner cannot review their own venue or vote on its reviews.
- A reply can be reported like a review. A reported reply is looked at by an administrator; it is not hidden in the meantime.
- If a venue changes hands, the earlier owner's replies stay, labelled as from the venue's earlier owner, and the new owner makes a fresh claim. We can end an owner's link at any time if it was obtained dishonestly or is misused.
- Changes an owner proposes to their listing go through the same approval as anyone's.
7. The most serious cases
- Suspected child abuse material is removed from view at once, the account is locked, and we refer it to the Australian Federal Police. Referring it is a legal duty.
- We follow removal notices from the eSafety Commissioner within the time the law sets.
- If a child is in immediate danger, call 000. You can report online child abuse to the Australian Centre to Counter Child Exploitation at www.accce.gov.au/report (opens in a new tab).
8. If you think a review is untrue and damages your reputation
Venues: the simplest answer is to claim your venue and reply publicly.
Anyone who believes that something on Babyccinos is defamatory of them can make a written complaint through the Contact us form or to hello@babyccinos.com.au. Tell us:
- your name;
- what the words or the picture are, and the address of the page;
- that you consider it defamatory, and why.
We aim to look at it and act within 7 days. We may hide the content while we look. We remove content only on a proper basis: a review is not removed because a venue disagrees with an honest opinion.
9. Adding and changing places
New places and changes to a listing are checked by an administrator before they appear. We tell you the result. We may decline a place that does not fit what Babyccinos lists; for example, we list only playgrounds and parks that are worth a trip.
10. If you are not satisfied
- Write to hello@babyccinos.com.au or use Contact us. A person will look again.
- For harmful content online, you can complain to the eSafety Commissioner: www.esafety.gov.au/report (opens in a new tab)
- For a consumer concern, you can contact your state or territory fair trading office, or the ACCC: www.accc.gov.au (opens in a new tab)